Ann Arbor Location

483 Little Lake Drive

Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103

Phone: (734) 668-4050

Fax: (734) 668-1860

Hours of Operation

MON-THU: 8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

FRIDAY: 8:30 AM - 3:00 PM

SAT-SUN: Closed

Dexter Location

3261 Broad Street
Dexter, Michigan 48130
Phone: (734) 426-4714

Fax: (734) 426-5911



Finn's JM&J Insurance Agency, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

Meet The Team

My name is David Bentley and I had attended Eastern Michigan University back when you could be called a Huron. I work in the Commercial Lines department and have been a proud member of Team Finn since 2014. I will always be happy and proud to brag about my son Grant, and I enjoy beating JD Finn on the bowling alley and golf course. Oh wait...I can’t beat him in golf, not even with a stroke a hole!

Commercial Lines

Dave Bentley

Specialty: Large and Small Apartments, restaurants, home and auto, life insurance


Since 1975


Education: Cleary College – Bachelor in Business Management


Served in the United States Marine Corp, 1966-1968, Vietnam Veteran


Married 45 years, wife is a retired teacher. Son is a Michigan State Graduate, currently a teacher in Chicago. Daughter is a University of Michigan Graduate, Cornell Law School and an attorney in Chicago.

John Carrizales

Licensed Customer Service Rep; specializes in personal lines home/auto/umbrella


Since Aug 2011 (7 years)


Education: Bachelor’s Degree from Aquinas College in Grand Rapids, Lumen Christi High School Graduate


I enjoy the team atmosphere and the great support system among the staff. I love animals, I volunteer at the Ella Sharp Museum in Jackson and I’m a Disney World fanatic.

Customer Service Rep

Mandy Desy

Education: Bachelors in Business Management and Business Marketing from Siena Heights University


I take pride in being honest with everyone whether they are a family member or someone I’ve just met. If I don’t have the best option for you I will be the first to tell you that.

Agent in Personal, Commercial, Life, Health, and Medicare

Ben Finn

Since 1989


Education: Bachelor from Michigan State University


I am married to Tava Finn who is a CPA at WSR Accountants also have 2 children Maggie and Josh, Avid golfer and bowler.

Agent and Fun Director

James D. Finn

33 years


Education: BA from MSU (Business Administration – Pre Law)


“I love what I do”


Robert Finn

Paul joined Finn's Insurance in September 2018 as Director of Healthcare Benefits with 18 years of experience as an Insurance Professional. Licensed in both Accident/Health and Life insurance, Paul has always taken a “service first” approach. 


Paul was born and raised in Birmingham, MI and attended Eastern Michigan University for undergraduate degree and MSU for his food science certification. After college he pursued his dream of becoming a PGA golf professional and spent approx. 10 years working in the business. He was recruited by Aflac in 2001 and worked alongside brokers and accounts to strengthen their benefit offerings. Along the way Paul has developed many key relationships in the Ann Arbor area and throughout southeast Michigan. He resides in Manchester with his wife Darci and their two children. Paul stills loves to play golf but really enjoys coaching his son's hockey and baseball teams.  When he's not coaching or working Paul loves to take the family up north skiing or fishing where they can all enjoy the beauty of Pure Michigan!

Director of Healthcare Benefits

Paul Majewski

High School Graduate


I have been with Finn’s for over 19 years. I have worked in all areas of the Agency through the years.


I am originally from Ohio. I have two wonderful children, Christopher and Brianna (Brie), that I raised as a single parent. Both have worked for Finn’s at some point, Brie currently does. I enjoy reading, watching sports and going to concerts.


Rhonda Mulligan

I have been a receptionist at Finns Insurance since January of 2018. As a receptionist, I feel a responsibility to ensure that our customers receive the best service possible. I am the first person they encounter when they call or come into our office, so I strive to be welcoming and professional. When not answering phones, I help with downloads and document processing. I feel very fortunate to work at a company like Finns where it truly is a team! 


Prior to this year, I was a stay at home mom, raising my now grown daughters. I have a Bachelor degree from the University of Michigan and I was in Bank Management for 8 years before my children were born. When I’m not at work, I enjoy golfing, reading, exercising, and travelling.


Jill Pollock

51 years


Education: BBA CIC

Agent, Commercial Lines, Personal Lines, Life

Brad Blair

My name is Margo Coleman, I'm one of the receptionists at Finns. I answer the phones, greet clients & do various secretarial duties. I was a stay at home wife/mom for many years & decided to work part time now that my 2 children are teenagers. I began working at Finns in February 2018, but I have known the family since I was a child. My mother worked here for over 30 years & my sister currently works at Finns, and has been here for over 30 years. What I like most about Finns is that they are very family oriented, and you can tell family is important to them. I also like the working environment & how well everyone gets along.


Margo Coleman

Personal Lines Department Specialist with Finns since May of 2010


Education: High School Graduate


I have been married for 32 years, we have two wonderful children, one of which who works here at the agency with me as well, and we currently have two grandsons. Working at Finns Insurance is like working with an extension of your family every day.

Personal Lines

Lisa Desy

Small to medium business insurance and finding solutions to complex personal and commercial accounts 


Since 1990


Education: Bachelor of Science – Michigan State University also Certified Insurance Councilor, Charter Life Underwriter


Avid boater, golfer and sports car enthusiast, baseball coach and love spending time outdoors in Michigan. Member of Dexter Downtown Development Authority, leader Dexter Relay for Life.

Executive Vice President

Douglas Finn

James W. Finn graduated bachelor Degree. Eastern Michigan University. Obtained Certification as a CLU, CHFC, CIC, and LIC. Taught many insurance classes. Chairman of Board. First licensed for Insurance in 1960. Protection for clients is the most important objective of my job.

James W. Finn

Executive Vice President of Operations Since 2005


Education: Bachelor’s degree, CIC

Executive Vice President

Steven Finn

25 years with Finn’s

Graduated from Pioneer High School

Claims Processor

Jennie Mannor

12 years

Education: Graduate of Western Michigan University

Executive Assistant

Brianna Mulligan

34 years on November 1st


Education: Attended Huron High School in Ann Arbor and received my Cosmetology License after High School before starting to work at Finn’s Insurance


I have been married for 29 years to my husband Michael. We have two grown daughters who are now married and living in Kentucky. We were graced with our adorable little grandson, Lucas in November 2016. We moved to Dexter before our daughters were in school and have never left. We loved the small town feel of Dexter, even while it continues to grow! I work in our Dexter office in both a sales capacity and assisting Doug Finn in operations. I enjoy assisting clients with servicing their existing policies, adding new policies, claims, billing and making sure clients know how much we appreciate them allowing us to service their insurance needs.

Sales Agent & Accountant Executive

Lesah K. Scott